Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. Menu

Tucked into a cozy corner at 180 S Main St in Bountiful, Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. serves up a menu that’s simple, playful, and downright irresistible, especially if you love classic flavors with a twist. The Always lineup anchors the experience with beloved staples like Fudge Brownie and Vanilla Bean, both rich and creamy with the kind of texture that makes you pause mid‑lick. Fresh Raspberry brings a bright, fruity zing that’s perfect on a sunny afternoon, while Caramel Cashew strikes that dreamy balance between sweet and salty with crunchy bits folded right in. You can’t skip Campfire S’mores either - it’s like a nostalgic trip to summer camp without the smoke in your eyes, all gooey marshmallow and chocolate goodness.

What keeps me coming back, though, are the For Now specials, which inject seasonal fun into every scoop. Utah Peach tastes like biting into ripe, sun‑kissed fruit on vacation, wonderfully refreshing and just slightly tangy. Then there’s Salted Cookie Dough, a crowd‑pleaser with big chunks of dough and a satisfying salt finish that turns every spoonful into a little moment of joy. What’s great is how these rotating flavors show off the creativity and care behind the menu, yet everything flows naturally from one scoop to the next. If you’re wrapping up a day in downtown Bountiful, this ice cream selection is the perfect way to end on a sweet note - familiar, fun, and always enjoyable.